Advertisment
A webpage on the advertisers’ website for flights to Frankfurt included the following statements:
“Book flights to Frankfurt (HHN)”
The facility to book flights was included and in the ‘To’ box, it stated:
“Frankfurt Hahn”.
The page also included a list of fares from various origin airports under the heading:
“Cheap flights to Frankfurt (HHN)”
The webpage included destination content about Frankfurt, including “Frankfurt travel guides” and descriptions of Frankfurt as “Germany’s financial and business centre”, encouraging consumers to “Book cheap flights to Frankfurt and discover a city of complimentary contrasts”
Complaint
Two complaints were received regarding advertising for flights to Frankfurt Hahn Airport. The complainants considered the advertising to be misleading as they had booked flights believing they were travelling to an airport located in Frankfurt but later discovered that Frankfurt-Hahn Airport was located approximately 120 km from Frankfurt. They considered the descriptor of the airport to be misleading, particularly for travellers unfamiliar with the region, and argued that the airport’s distance from Frankfurt was not made sufficiently clear during the booking process. One complainant referred to a German court case which they said, meant that the name of the airport ‘Frankfurt Hahn’ could not be used unless the distance to Frankfurt was included in advertising.
Response
The advertisers stated that the destination was not advertised as ‘Frankfurt’, as throughout the booking flow the airport was identified by its established name (Frankfurt Hahn) and the IATA code (HHN) and that the screenshots provided with the complaints showed this. They said that the designation was descriptive, accurate, and intended to assist passengers in identifying the geographical area served by the airport and that the reference to Frankfurt provided a recognisable point of reference in the broader geographical area in which the airport was located.
They stated that the use of a principal city or metropolitan area to identify airports serving the wider region, including where the airport was located outside the administrative boundaries of that city, long- established and widely accepted industry practice. They pointed to other airports like London Stansted, Paris Beauvais, Brussels Charleroi, and Milan Bergamo. They said that such a reference was of particular assistance to passengers who were unfamiliar with the local geography, while the ‘Hahn’ element and the ‘HHN’ code made it clear that this was a distinct airport and not the main city airport.
The advertisers said that they had operated to and from Frankfurt Hahn for more than two decades and so the airport was widely recognised as a separate airport.
In response to the reference by one complainant of a German court case involving a different airline, they said that, to their best of their knowledge the matter had been in 2002 and there was no judgement against the advertisers on the basis that consumers generally understood Frankfurt Hahn to be a separate airport located over 100km from Frankfurt. They said that no injunction remains in force and that there was no German decision restricting the use of the name, therefore, the suggestion that a German court had banned the name was incorrect.
Finally, the advertisers stated that, without prejudice, and in the interests of providing passengers with the greatest possible clarity, they would update their travel guide page so that all references to ‘Frankfurt’ would appear together with ‘Frankfurt Hahn’ and the ‘HHN’ airport travel code where relevant.
Conclusion
Complaints Not Upheld.
The Independent Complaints Council considered the detail of the complaint and the advertisers’ response.
The Council noted that the advertising had included both the city name and the airport code and name.
The Council noted the requirements of the Code that a marketing communication should not mislead, or be likely to mislead, by inaccuracy, ambiguity, exaggeration, omission or otherwise (S. 4.1) and that advertisers should not exploit the credulity, inexperience or lack of knowledge of consumers (S. 4.4).
In this case, the Council noted that the destination airport was not a new destination, as the advertiser had operated there for over 20 years and that consumers were provided with information to identify the destination airport. In the circumstances, the Council did not consider that the advertising was in breach of the Code on the grounds raised.
The Council noted the advertisers’ intention to update the webpage to ensure all references made included the airport code and/or ‘Hahn’
Action Required:
No further action required.