Advertisment
The advertisement promoted Freenow’s “Comfort” taxi service for Valentine’s weekend. It featured the headline “Upgrade Valentine’s” and stated: “Nothing kills the romantic vibe quicker than a dodgy journey into town.”
The advertisement stated: –
“Valentine’s weekend in Dublin is going to be hectic. While everyone else is on the curb playing musical chairs with standard cars, you could be stepping out of a Comfort. Think top- rated drivers, extra legroom and a car that actually matches the effort you put into your hair.”
Complaint
There were three complaints against the advertising.
Issue 1:
The complainants stated that the advertisement unfairly portrayed standard licensed taxis as inferior by referring to a “dodgy journey” and contrasting them with the advertisers’ “Comfort” service. They argued that all licensed taxis are subject to the same regulatory and safety requirements and considered that the advertisement denigrated drivers operating outside the “Comfort” category.
Issue 2:
The complainants argued that the advertisement implied a level of quality or safety not supported by any recognised licensing distinction and misled consumers into believing that the promoted service provided a materially superior standard of service.
Issue 3:
One complainant also expressed concern that the service was only available to app users with registered payment cards and that this limitation was not made clear in the advertisement.
Response
Issue 1:
The advertisers stated that the advertisement was a “light-hearted, tongue-in-cheek” Valentine’s email intended to contrast the difficulty of hailing a taxi on a busy weekend with the convenience and premium experience of booking a Comfort vehicle through the app. They contended that the reference to consumers “playing musical chairs with standard cars” would be understood by consumers as a hyperbolic and tongue-in-cheek promotional statement rather than a genuine comparison with other taxi services. They denied that the advertisement unfairly attacked or denigrated standard taxi services, noting that the majority of Freenow trips are completed using standard taxis and that drivers are licensed professionals. However, they acknowledged that the use of the word “dodgy” may have caused offence and stated that they would refrain from using such terminology in future.
Issue2:
The advertisers argued that the ad was not misleading and clearly identified the features of the Comfort Fleet, namely “top-rated drivers” and “extra legroom”. The advertisers stated that the Comfort Fleet allows passengers to choose newer, more spacious vehicles and that drivers must meet specific criteria, including driving a taxi less than four years old, having at least 90cm of passenger legroom, using an eligible vehicle and maintaining a passenger rating of at least 4.8 stars. They maintained that the claims regarding “top-rated drivers” and “extra legroom” were capable of substantiation, as all Comfort Fleet drivers and vehicles were required to meet the relevant eligibility criteria.
Issue 3:
They also stated that the communication was sent to existing Freenow customers who would already understand how the app operates.
Conclusion
Complaints Upheld In Part.
The Complaints Council considered the detail of the complaints and the advertisers’ response.
Issue 1- Complaints Upheld:
While the Council acknowledged the commentary that the advertisement was intended to be light-hearted and tongue-in-cheek, it considered that the reference to a “dodgy journey into town” went beyond merely highlighting the benefits of the Comfort service. The Council considered that the statement created the impression that standard taxi services were inferior or less desirable than the advertised service. The Council therefore concluded that the advertisement unfairly denigrated standard taxi services and was in breach of Sections 4.31, 4.32 and 4.34 of the Code.
Issue 2- Complaints Not Upheld:
The Council noted the complaint that the advertisement implied a level of quality or safety not supported by any recognised licensing distinction. However, they also noted the commentary that drivers participating in the Comfort Fleet were required to meet specified criteria, including vehicle age requirements, minimum passenger legroom requirements and a minimum passenger rating of 4.8 stars. The Council considered that consumers would understand the claims relating to “top-rated drivers” and “extra legroom” as objective claims about the features of the Comfort service and that the advertisement was unlikely to mislead consumers regarding the nature of the Comfort service.
Accordingly, the Council did not consider that the advertising was in breach of the Code on the basis suggested in the complaints.
Issue 3- Complaint Not Upheld:
The Council noted that the advertising was sent to existing customers of the service. They considered that consumers would be aware that app services generally required an account and a payment method to avail of the service. They did not consider the advertising in breach of the Code on the basis suggested in the complaint.
Action Required:
The advertisement must not reappear in its current form. Care should be taken to avoid language that is denigratory to competitors.