Advertisment
The advertising was a webpage that was presented as part of the advertisers’ Furzefield development site.
Text on the site read: –
‘Glenveagh is pleased to introduce Furzefield, a striking new collection of beautifully designed family homes in the heart of the bustle and excitement of Swords, County Dublin.’
Further down the page, a heading stating “Everything is Within Your Reach” was displayed on the page. Beneath this, a block of text read: –
Furzefield connects you to it all, conveniently located just a short drive from Dublin city centre, Drogheda and Navan with the M1 and M50 motorways just minutes away. For those who prefer public transport, regular buses, including the Swords Express, serve Dublin City Centre and beyond, so you can enjoy a stress-free daily commute.
Below this text, a series of informational panels was presented, in which nearby amenities and travel times were listed. Dublin City Centre, Dublin Airport, Donabate Beach and Swords Pavilions Shopping Centre were each identified, with corresponding travel times indicated: –
Swords Pavilions Shopping Centre
10 minutes
Dublin City Centre
35 minutes
Dublin Airport
17 minutes
Donabate Beach
21 minutes
A panel showing nearby bus routes, including Swords Express and routes 41, 41b and 41c, was also displayed: –
Nearby Bus Routes
Swords Express/41/41b/41c
Complaint
The complainant claimed that certain elements of the advertisement were misleading.
Issue 1:
They claimed that the bus routes were not as close as the impression the advertising gave. They said that they were at least ten minutes’ walk from the development. One route that was mentioned was the 41b that they said was a very limited service with a Monday to Friday service comprised of only 5 buses.
Issue 2:
The complainant said that it was not possible to drive to Dublin City Centre in 35 minutes as claimed by the advertising.
Issue 3:
The complainant said that they believed the claim that the development had been located in the ‘heart of the bustle and excitement of Swords’ could not have been the case as the development was 2.5 kilometres by car from the Main Street or a 25-minute walk.
Response
The advertisers appreciated the opportunity to answer the issues raised in the complaint and respectfully submitted that the advertising was not in breach of the Code as the claims made by their advertising were factual.
Issue 1
On the issue of bus routes, they advertisers said that they disagreed with the complaint. They said that their advertising listed the “Swords Express / 41 / 41B / 41C” as the routes which served the local area. This they said was accurate. They said that according to Dublin Bus and the National Transport Authority, the Route 41 and Route 41C operated as core services between Swords Manor and Lower Abbey Street in Dublin city centre. The advertisers said that each ran approximately every 20 minutes and provided a combined frequency of a bus approximately every 10 minutes along most of the route. They said that route 41B (Rolestown – Lower Abbey Street) operated daily from 06:20 to 22:45 across its 62 stops. The advertisers said that this demonstrated that there was not a service of “just 5 buses” per weekday. They also pointed to The Swords Express service which operated approximately every 30 minutes from Swords Manor to Dublin city centre via the Dublin Port Tunnel.
The advertisers went on to say that they had described the bus routes as ‘nearby’ and that this descriptor had not stated, implied, or quantified any particular walking time to any specific bus stop. The advertisers said that the 41C, 41X, 43 and Swords Express services stop on Glen Ellan Road, which directly served the Applewood / Mooretown / Rathbeale corridor in which Furzefield sat. Further, multiple bus stops on Rathbeale Road and Glen Ellan Road lay within a typical short walk of the development. The descriptor “Nearby Bus Routes” therefore they claimed was therefore accurate and not misleading under Code section 4.1.
Issue 2:
The advertisers’ said that the 35-minute drive time stated on the website was consistent with widely accepted, independently published estimates for the journey from Swords to Dublin city centre via the M1 motorway and Dublin Port Tunnel. The same approximate journey time was given by RTÉ News, Wikivoyage, and a range of independent transport sources, and was the same headline journey time used by the Swords Express commuter service operating the route.
They said that the website had not stated that the journey took 35 minutes at all times in all conditions but that the figure represented a reasonable and substantiated typical journey time and was, in their opinion, not in breach of Code sections 4.1, 4.9 and 4.10.
Issue 3:
On the issue of Furzefield as having been described as “in the heart of the bustle and excitement of Swords, County Dublin” being misleading because the development was approximately 2.5 km from Swords Main Street.
On this, the advertisers said that Furzefield was located within Swords, County Dublin. They said that Swords was a town of approximately 41,000 people, was the administrative capital of Fingal, and was a single, well-connected community. They said that the descriptor “in the heart of the bustle and excitement of Swords” was plainly an evocative and aspirational characterisation of life in the Swords community as a whole – the town’s amenities, atmosphere and sense of community, and was not and could not reasonably be understood by a consumer to be, a precise geographical claim that the development sat at the geometric centre of Swords Main Street.
The advertisers referred to Code section 2.4(c), which they noted required that compliance be assessed by reference to the likely audience and the context of the marketing communication taken as a whole. They said that the same page on which the descriptor appeared also featured a clearly labelled local-amenities panel quantifying drive times to Swords Pavilions Shopping Centre (10 minutes), Dublin Airport (17 minutes), Donabate Beach (21 minutes) and Dublin city centre (35 minutes). They considered that a consumer viewing the page in context was given clear, transparent information from which to form a properly informed view of the development’s location relative to nearby amenities. They said in their opinion there was no inaccuracy, ambiguity or omission of a kind capable of materially misleading the consumer.
Further Information:
The ASA Executive reviewed the timetables for the bus routes 41, 41b and 41c and noted that while 41b had limited frequency, both 41 and 41c had significant frequency over all days, for example, on weekdays the 41 routes had circa 60 journeys both in and outbound.
The ASA Executive noted from an online search that the walk from the bus stops to the development were stated to be either 8 or 9 minutes.
Conclusion
Complaint Upheld In Part.
The Complaints Council considered the detail of the complaint and the advertisers’ response.
Issue 1- Complaint Not Upheld:
The Council noted the ASA Executives review of bus timetables and considered that the claim that there were regular bus services was accurate. In relation to the description of the bus stops as ‘nearby’ the Council also considered the descriptor was accurate. In the circumstances they did not consider that the advertising was in breach of the Code on the basis suggested in the complaint.
Issue 2 – Complaint Upheld:
The Council noted the claim made was “Dublin City Centre 35 mins” and that there was no indication in the advertisement that the journey was via the Port Tunnel, nor was the destination within the City Centre provided. The Council considered previous adjudications that found that, unless specified, ‘Dublin City Centre’ should be defined as O’Connell Street. The Council were aware that journey times could vary given traffic conditions and routes, and that simply stating, “Dublin City Centre 35 mins” without a qualification that it was via the Port Tunnel and that the travel time was ‘from’, could imply that all routes into the City Centre took ’35 mins’.
The Council concluded therefore that the stated journey time was likely to mislead and therefore in breach of Code section 4.1 and 4.4 for omission that the journey time was with use of the Port Tunnel.
Issue 3 – Complaint Upheld:
The Council noted the commentary that the descriptor “in the heart of the bustle and excitement of Swords” was plainly an evocative and aspirational characterisation of life in the Swords community as a whole. While they agreed that such a claim did not have to be linked to a precise geographical location, they noted that the advertised development was at the edge of the town as currently developed. In the circumstances they considered the claim “in the heart of the bustle and excitement of Swords” was likely to mislead on grounds of exaggeration and therefore in breach of 4.1 of the Code.
Action Required:
The advertising should not reappear in its current form. The Council advised advertisers to ensure care when advertising the location and distance of developments in advertising.