Advertisment
The advertisement appeared as a sponsored article and promoted Procydin, a food supplement containing grape seed extract, vitamin C and vitamin E.
The headline stated:
“This new supplement is helping people with arthritis, pain relief, and skin health.”
The article stated the following:
“As we get older, many of us become more prone to joint pain, making it more difficult to live our lives as comfortably as we used to.
The good news is that a new natural antioxidant food supplement is now available that can help relieve stiff or aching joints, as well as contribute to cardiovascular health, skin health and more.
Procydin is a natural supplement containing grape seed extract, vitamin C and vitamin E. Taking it each morning can help reduce inflammation throughout your body, allowing you to feel more like yourself again. The supplement also improves blood flow, strengthens your skin and tissue, and boosts the performance of your immune system.
Natural ingredients found in Procydin include phenolic acids, anthocyanins, flavonoids, and oligomeric proanthocyanidin complexes (OPCs), all of which serve the purpose of healing and protecting your body against whatever damage it may have taken over the years.
Sometimes referred to as ‘Nature’s Vitamin P’ OPCs are gaining attention for their role in supporting vascular health, reducing oxidative stress and helping the body manage everyday inflammation.
Due to modern diets and habits, there are certain crucial OPCs that we might be missing, which is exactly why Procydin can make such a difference to your life, especially if you are 45 or over. These vital nutrients can help with the process of healthy ageing, and are available over-the-counter at health stores and pharmacies across Ireland now.
It’s easy to take and comes in a bottle of 60 capsules, so you can give it a go for two months and see what a difference it can make to your quality of life.
Procydin provides the boost of antioxidants the body needs to balance out the deficiencies caused by contemporary living. As a result, it may help to prevent oxidative stresses and the many diseases associated with it. Procydin is a trusted supplement, and while it is new to Ireland, it’s been on sale in South Africa for 20 years.
To learn more about how Procydin could improve your quality of life, visit
procydin.ie or visit your local health store or pharmacy to buy now.”
Complaint
Two complaints were received regarding the advertising.
Issue 1:
One complainant believed that the advertisement contained health claims that were not compliant with European legislation governing health claims for foods and food supplements.
Issue 2:
The second complainant challenged several claims in the advertisement, including references to arthritis relief, reduced inflammation, improved blood flow, enhanced immune function, vascular health, healthy ageing and disease prevention. The complainant considered that the advertisement made broad claims regarding the product’s health benefits and disease-related effects which were not adequately substantiated and appeared to exceed the claims permitted for food supplements. They further argued that the advertisement implied that consumers may suffer from nutritional deficiencies due to modern lifestyles and that the product could address such deficiencies. The complainant believed that the overall impression conveyed by the advertisement was likely to mislead consumers regarding the product’s efficacy, health benefits and ability to prevent or alleviate medical conditions.
Response
Issue 1:
The advertisers accepted that a number of the health claims contained in the article were inappropriate for a food supplement and exceeded the claims permitted under EU legislation. They stated that, while the product contained vitamins C and E for which authorised EU health claims exist, the wording used in the article went beyond those authorised claims. They provided examples of claims relating to immune system performance and skin and tissue strength that exceeded the permitted wording and stated that, in future, only authorised claims, or equivalent wording, would be used where the relevant conditions were met.
The advertisers also acknowledged that references to “healthy ageing”, “skin health”, “vascular health” and improving quality of life constituted general health claims that were not supported by specific authorised health claims. In relation to grape seed extract, they referred to several “on hold” botanical claims but accepted that the wording used in the article exceeded those claims. They stated that their intention had been to educate consumers using approved claims associated with the product’s ingredients but accepted that the wording used went beyond what was permissible and expressed regret that the copy had been approved in that form.
The advertisers stated that they had requested the withdrawal of the sponsored article, suspended further advertising for the product pending a regulatory review, and confirmed that the disputed claims would not be repeated.
Issue 2:
The advertisers said that they did not seek to defend claims that the product helped people with arthritis, provided pain relief, relieved stiff or aching joints, reduced inflammation, healed bodily damage, improved blood flow, prevented diseases, or remedied deficiencies caused by contemporary living. They acknowledged that such statements were inappropriate for a food supplement and should not have appeared in the article.
The advertisers accepted that references suggesting consumers were “missing crucial OPCs” or suffering from deficiencies caused by modern lifestyles could imply that a balanced diet was inadequate. They acknowledged that these references, together with claims regarding disease prevention and other health benefits, went beyond the claims permitted for food supplements.
The advertisers stated that the article had been withdrawn and confirmed that the identified wording would not be used again.
Conclusion
Complaints Upheld.
The Independent Complaints Council considered the complaint and the advertisers’ response, including that the advertisement had been withdrawn.
Issue 1- Complaint Upheld:
The Council noted that the advertisement contained a number of health claims, including that it was “helping people with arthritis, pain relief, and skin health”; that it could “help relieve stiff or aching joints, as well as contribute to cardiovascular health, skin health and more”; that it could “help reduce inflammation throughout your body”; and that the supplement “improves blood flow, strengthens your skin and tissue, and boosts the performance of your immune system”. The Council considered that consumers were likely to understand these statements as objective claims regarding the health benefits of the product.
The Council noted the requirements of the Code that only health claims listed as authorised in the EU Register, or claims that would have the same meaning to the consumer, may be used in marketing communications (S 8.8) and the requirement that a marketing communication that contains nutrition or health claims should be supported by documentary evidence substantiating that they meet the conditions of use associated with the relevant claim, as specified in the EU Register (S.8.9).
The Council noted from the response that the advertisers had accepted that a number of the claims made in the advertising as to the benefits of Vitamin C and E in the product, such as “boosts the performance of your immune system” and “strengthens your skin and tissue “had exceeded those authorised under EU legislation governing foods and food supplements and that some general health claims made were not supported by specific authorised health claims. In addition, the Council considered that references to general health and wellbeing benefits, including healthy ageing and vascular health, had not been accompanied by specific authorised health claims. In the circumstances, the Council considered that the advertisement was in breach of Sections 8.8, 8.9 and 8.11 of the Code.
Issue 2- Complaint Upheld:
The Council noted that the advertisement stated that the product was “helping people with arthritis, pain relief, and skin health”, could “help relieve stiff or aching joints”, “reduce inflammation throughout your body”, “improve blood flow” and “help to prevent oxidative stresses and the many diseases associated with it”.
The Council noted the requirements of the Code that references to general benefits of a nutrient or food for overall good health or health-related well-being are acceptable only if accompanied by a specific authorised health claim (S 8.11); and that while a reduction of disease risk claims are acceptable if authorised by the European Commission, claims that state or imply a food prevents, treats or cures human disease are not acceptable in marketing communications for food products (S 8.14).
The Council also noted the requirement that marketing communications should not suggest or imply that a well-balanced diet needs to be augmented by vitamins or minerals on a regular basis. Advertisers may offer supplements as a safeguard and may refer to the vitamin and mineral content of a particular product but should not suggest that there is a widespread vitamin or mineral deficiency. Marketing communications should not imply that supplements will guard against dietary deficiency, elevate mood or enhance performance and supplements should not be promoted as a substitute for a healthy diet. Marketing communications should not claim that a food supplement is capable of preventing, treating or curing disease (S 8.38).
The Council noted the response and acknowledged the action taken by the advertisers to remove the advertisement. They considered that consumers were likely to understand the statements in the advertisement as claims that the product could prevent, treat or alleviate disease and medical conditions. In the circumstances the Council considered the advertising was in breach of Sections 8.11, 8.14 and 8.38 of the Code.
Action Required:
The Council, while noting that the advertisement had been removed, required that the advertisement should not appear in its current form again.