Advertisment
A story on the influencer’s social media account featured Bare By Vogue tan. Each image showed that a filter titled ‘Paris filter’ had been used.
Image 1:
An image of the influencer wearing the tan.
On screen text stated:
“25% Off plus Free gift till midnight!”
A link to the advertisers’ website was on screen
“This is 2 coats of the liquid shade Dark and then gradual on each morning after shower. Day THREE!! It’s just the best tan @bare”
Image 2:
An image of tan being applied.
On screen text stated:
“NO MINIMUM SPEND
Free all (sic) any order using code TRISHA25”
A link titled ‘enjoy’ was included together with the brand’s handle.
Image 3:
A further image of the tan being applied.
On screen text stated:
“NO MINIMUM SPEND
Free all (sic) any order using code TRISHA25”
A link titled ‘enjoy’ was included together with the brand’s handle.
(More information on filter: – https://www.instagram.com/popular/instagram-paris-filter/?hl=en)
Complaint
The complainant objected to the story on the following grounds.
Issue 1:
That the content had not featured any clear disclosure such as #Ad.
Issue 2:
The complainant noted that a filter had been used which they considered changed the appearance of the skin and could therefore enhance the appearance of the effects of the tan.
Response
Advertisers’ Response:
Issue 1:
The advertisers said that they worked with the creator regularly and, felt it was possible that the appropriate advertising disclosure may have been omitted inadvertently. They said they provided briefing documentation outlining all relevant disclosure requirements; but that creators were ultimately responsible for ensuring their content complied with the applicable advertising guidelines and platform requirements. On further review they saw that they did not specifically call out the disclosure requirement, which was due to their understanding that responsibility for applying the relevant disclosure tools remained with the creator.
They said that they routinely discussed disclosure requirements verbally with creators and agencies, and from what they could ascertain this appeared to have been an isolated oversight on the creator’s part while travelling. They said that they had not encountered this issue previously, and asked for guidance on how they could further strengthen their processes to help prevent similar situations in the future.
They said that they would be addressing the matter directly with the creator in writing and providing clear guidance on the importance of using the appropriate disclosure tools and ensuring transparency in all future content. They said that they would also review and update their own briefing processes to further strengthen compliance with advertising guidelines.
They said that if a mistake had been made, it was certainly not intentional, and they were committed to learning from this experience and taking any necessary steps to improve processes.
Issue 2:
The advertisers said that they do not ask creators to alter their content through the use of filters or other modifications that could misrepresent product performance. They said that authenticity and transparency were important to their brand, and they prided themselves on maintaining these standards across all partnerships.
Influencers’ Response:
Issue 1:
The influencer said that they had every single frame labelled with paid partnership. They said that the screenshots provided with the complaint were not correct as they label all their advertisements.
Issue 2:
The influencer did not provide a response to this aspect of the complaint.
Further Information:
Issue 1:
The influencer provided two images of different frames from the story that had included the disclosure “paid partnership”.
Further images were provided which required permissions to open which were requested from the influencer by the Executive, however, no further response was received.
Conclusion
The Complaints Council considered the detail of the complaint and the advertisers’ response.
Issue 1 – Complaint Upheld:
The Council noted the Code requirements that marketing communications should be clear that they are marketing communications and also the requirements of the joint guidance published by the Advertising Standards Authority and the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) on disclosing advertising content, which required that advertising content should have one of three primary labels as a disclosure; #AD, a platform provided tool or #Gifted, depending on the content, and that the disclosure should be the first word in any text block. The Council considered that by providing for specific disclosures, consumer recognition that content is advertising would be enhanced.
The Council also noted that the joint guidance stated that “Platform provided labels: If a platform provides labels, you should make sure that this is enough to guarantee that the advertising is instantly recognisable for your audience. If not, you should use an additional primary advertisement label in the post (i.e. #Ad or #gifted)”
In this case the Council noted that some of the images provided with the complaint had included the audio description rather than the platform label ‘paid partnership’, whereas one image provided, did not appear to include the ‘paid partnership’ label. They also noted the two images of different frames from the same content that had been provided by the influencer which featured the ‘paid partnership’ label.
The Council was aware that when audio was used, its description was alternated on screen with a platform provided tool if used. The Council considered that because the platform provided label was not always visible, the content was not adequately disclosed as advertising and was therefore in breach of Section 3.31 and 3.32 of the Code.
Issue 2 – Complaint Upheld:
The Complaints Council noted the Code requirement that before offering a marketing communication for publication, advertisers should satisfy themselves that they will be able to provide documentary evidence to substantiate all claims that consumers are likely to regard as objective. They noted that the story frames had shown that a filter was used, and that no explanation had been provided as to why the particular filter used would not render the content misleading by affecting the product’s appearance. In the absence of such evidence, the Council considered that the content was in breach of the Code Section 3.10, 4.01, 4.04, 4.09 and 4.10.
Action Required:
The content should not appear in its current form again. The Council advised advertisers and influencers that, where platform provided tools were not always visible, an additional primary label should be used so that the content is instantly recognisable as commercial.