Vodafone considered that the advertising of the €100 off broadband offer was misleading as it was being advertised as a time limited offer through messaging and the use of countdown timers when the substantive terms and prices of the offer remained unchanged after such messaging had been removed or amended and countdown clocks had expired.
The complainants said that they were of the view that, while extending an offer on a once-off basis and for a genuine reason was not a proscribed commercial practice, it was subject to the requirements of transparency and that the promotion and the extension should not mislead customers (including by applying artificial urgency or by undermining the original terms of the promotion which consumers may have signed up to). In this case, they considered that this practice had created an artificial sense of urgency and risked misleading consumers as to the genuine availability and duration of the offers.
The advertisers said that they had run a series of €100 bill credit offer promotions and €50 bill credit offer promotions during the time period in question, which operated at different times and were subject to different terms and conditions. They provided details of the promotions below:
| Offer | Period between January 2026 and May 2026 | Countdown timer | Outcome |
|---|
| €100 bill credit | 1 January – 31 March 2026 | Yes (26 March 2026 – 31 March 2026) | Expired in accordance with countdown timer and replaced by €50 bill credit offer |
| €50 bill credit | 1 April 2026 – 21 April 2026 | No | Replaced by €100 bill credit offer |
| €100 bill credit | 22 April 2026 – 3 May 2026 | Yes (29 April 2026 – 3 May 2026) | Expired in accordance with countdown timer and replaced by €50 bill credit offer |
| €50 bill credit | 4 May 2026 – 19 May 2026 | No | Replaced by €100 bill credit offer |
| €100 credit | From 20 May 2026 | Yes (28 May 2026 – 3 June 2026) | Offer extended on 3 June following review; revised promotional period reflected in updated offer terms. |
The advertisers said that during the January to March 2026 period, the €100 bill credit offer remained available to consumers over an extended period. They said that prior to 26th March 2026, they did not use a countdown timer in connection with that offer. They said that the first countdown timer associated with that €100 bill credit offer appeared on 26th March 2026 and this offer expired in accordance with the countdown timer on 31st March and was subsequently replaced with a separate €50 bill credit offer operating under different terms and conditions that ran from 1st April until 21st April 2026.
They said that the second countdown time associated with the €100 bill credit offer appeared 29th April and ended on 3rd May 2026 at the expiry of the countdown timer and advise that this offer was followed by a €50 bill credit offer that ran from 4th to 19th May 2026 under different terms and conditions to the preceding €100 bill credit offer.
The advertisers said that on 28th May 2026, a countdown timer was introduced on the eir website with the intention to remove that €100 bill credit offer on 3rd June 2026, in line with the terms and conditions of the offer in place at that time. They advised that, following a review of the promotion on 3rd June 2026, they decided to extend the offer for a further period. They said that the terms and conditions of that offer were updated on 4th June to reflect a revised end date of 22nd June 2026. They said that on the 23rd of June, the same offer, now not subject to a countdown timer, was extended until 30th June, and the terms and conditions were updated at the bottom of the offer webpage to reflect the extension. They said that in each case, customers remained entitled to receive the €100 bill credit offer during the revised promotional period.
They said that they accepted that they had on one occasion, 3rd June, extended an offer after a countdown timer had expired, they noted the complainant’s acknowledgement in its complaint that “extending an offer on a once-off basis and for a genuine reason was not a proscribed commercial practice”. They said that they did not accept that they had engaged in a campaign to mislead consumers over a prolonged period of time.
They said that the existence of separate €50 bill credit offers served to undermine the incorrect allegation that consumers were presented with the same €100 bill credit offer between January 2026 and May 2026. They noted that the complainants asserted that “the underlying offer does not materially change” and that the €100 bill credit offers “remained unchanged”, which they refuted. They said that that overall consumer impression could not be assessed on the basis of the allegation that a single €100 bill credit offer remained continuously available throughout that period.
In response to the complaint regarding the advertising on the third-party comparison platform, the advertisers said that they noted that the complaint referred to the existence of the €100 bill credit offer in place at the time and also on promotional labels such as “Ends Soon”. They said that it was important to distinguish between the underlying offer and the manner in which information was presented on a third-party comparison platform. They said that during the relevant period, they provided the platform with offer information, including offer terms and the updated end date (where the particular offer was extended). They said that the platform used the information to decide how to market the offer on its platform and generate its own promotional labels. They said that while the screenshots may demonstrate that an offer appeared on the platform at a particular point in time, they did not necessarily reflect the specific advertising claims that appeared on the eir website. In particular, they said that the complaint did not identify any equivalent “Ends Soon” or “1 Day Left” messaging appearing on the eir website during the January-March 2026 period. In view of this they requested caution treating promotional labels generated by a third-party comparison platform as equivalent to consumer-facing advertising claims made by the advertiser themselves.
The advertiser noted that the Code provided that compliance was assessed by reference to the probable effect of a marketing communication when taken as a whole and in context, therefore, they submitted that the relevant question was the overall impression conveyed to consumers by the specific advertisement under consideration at the time it appeared, rather than a retrospective aggregation of multiple campaigns over several months. They stated that a consumer viewing a promotion in March 2026 was not assessing that promotion against future campaigns or promotions that might appear months later and equally, a consumer viewing a promotion in June 2026 was reacting to the advertisement at that time.
The advertisers considered that the complaint was based on the fact that certain promotional periods were subsequently extended, which were alleged to have created an artificial sense of urgency and risked misleading customers. They said that, while the fact of a subsequent extension may form part of the context in which an advertisement was assessed, the existence of an extension did not automatically establish that the overall impression originally conveyed to consumers was misleading or likely to mislead. They contended that the fact that a promotion was subsequently extended did not establish that any such misleading representation was made and the existence of a subsequent extension could not, of itself, amount to proof of a breach of the Code.
They considered that the complaint had not identified any specific claim that was false when it was made, nor did it provide evidence that consumers were misled as to the nature of the offer available to them at the time they made their purchasing decision. They said that were presented with the offer available at the relevant time and, where they chose to proceed, received the benefit of the promotion then being advertised.