Advertisment
The advertisement was published on the influencer’s Instagram account and identified as a “Paid partnership with jshealthvitamins.” The video prominently displayed the text “Code SARAHB” for its duration and included an affiliate link with the call to action “GET YOURS HERE,” directing viewers to purchase the advertised product.
The Influencer featured throughout the story holding two plastic vitamin bottles with screw-top lids and a printed label displaying the advertisers’ name, and the name of the product “Detox and Debloat”. The Influencer then provided the following information:
“So, this is just your reminder that my Code for JSHealth is still active. I have just nearly finished this bottle, and we are going onto this one, and that is because my husband keeps using them as well. Detox and Debloat are a fantastic aid for your digestive system to get rid of ‘bloatness’ in your stomach. So, if you are someone sitting at home right now and you are suffering with that ugh feeling, blah feeling, but when I say that, if you are suffering with it, you’ll know what I’m talking about, you’ll get me. You’ll just feel sluggish and bloated, not great, and there’s no confidence and your conscious. I promise you, Detox and Debloat will work. It is science backed ingredients, quality, high quality ingredients, it’s proven by thousands and I absolutely love it. 2 a day, after food, one in the morning and one in the evening, or I might take one in the morning and one at lunchtime, it depends but consistency is key.
It is not a weight loss supplement, but it is really going to benefit the ‘bloatness’ in your stomach, but for me once I am making good choices with my food, right, not doing the dog, making good choices with my food, being really mindful, drinking plenty of water, taking my Detox and Debloat, the confidence I gain is incredible. I am not someone; look I have 3 kids. I am not someone who is flat stomach {sic}, I am never going to have a flat stomach. For me it just gives me that confidence that I can put on a pair of jeans and wear the T-shirt inside, and that I am that bit more confident in myself. I feel better in myself, and what stands out to me is that when I’m taking the product, I can notice the difference, but when I stop taking the product and I’m not consistent, I also can feel the difference. And that is why I love Detox and Debloat because it just gives me that confidence in my body and takes that ‘bloatness’ away.
So, remember, consistency is key. Two a day, one in the morning, and one in the evening and thank me later”.
Complaint
Issue 1
The complainant said they believed the Influencer had previously admitted to the use of weight loss medications, and therefore, their claims regarding bloating could not be regarded as accurate. The complainant considered it to be misleading by omission and implication to attribute body confidence and improvements to that feeling of ‘bloat’ while omitting that the transformation was perhaps due to prescription weight loss injections.
Issue 2
The complainant queried whether there was substantiation available for the claims made in the advertising i.e. “Science backed” “Proven by thousands” and “I promise you Detox and Debloat will work”.
Issue 3
The complainant considered that the advertising had implied that slimming/body shape benefits (flatter looking stomach from no bloating, being able to wear jeans and a t shirt tucked in, feeling better in her body) could be obtained from taking a vitamin product and that this claim was contrary to the requirements for slimming and weight control claims that could be made in marketing communications.
Response
Advertisers’ Response:
Issue 1
The advertisers said the content in question had featured the Influencer discussing her personal experience with their supplement. They said she had clearly stated that ‘this is not a weight loss supplement’, and she had positioned the product as supporting digestion and helping to alleviate feelings of bloating, based on her individual experience.
Issue 2
The advertiser addressed the specific concerns raised by the complainant as follows:
• “Proven by thousands” had, they said, referred to the volume of customer reviews and feedback available on their website, which reflected a broad range of consumer experiences.
• “Science-backed ingredients” was, they said, a general, non-specific descriptor reflecting their brand’s commitment to formulating with ingredients supported by existing research. As a science-focused brand, they said, their ethos was to let research guide their ingredient choices, and this phrase had communicated that philosophy.
• “I promise you Detox and Debloat will work” had, they said, reflected the influencer’s personal opinion and testimonial, rather than being an objective or guaranteed claim.
Issue 3
The advertisers said that the references within the advertising content to confidence, comfort in clothing, and “feeling better” were subjective and had related to overall wellbeing. The Influencer had, they said, referred to feeling her best through a combination of factors, including consistent supplement use, alongside balanced lifestyle choices such as mindful nutrition, regular movement (e.g. walking), and staying hydrated. They said these statements were not intended to imply that the supplement alone delivered body-shape or slimming outcomes.
The advertisers said they wished to clarify that they could not comment on, or disclose, any individual’s medical history or prescribed medications within advertising content, and they would never do so. They said the content had focused solely on the individual’s personal experience with the product.
Influencer’s Response:
The Influencer did not address all aspects of the complaint but said that the product in question was not a weight loss supplement nor did it aid weight loss. They said they used the product for gut health, digestive system, and to keep everything moving as it should. Weight-loss or not, they said, ‘bloatness’ occurred no matter what a person’s size.
Conclusion
Complaint Upheld In Part.
The Independent Complaints Council considered the detail of the complaint, and both the advertisers’ and influencer’s responses.
Issues 1 and 3- Complaint Not Upheld:
The Council noted that the advertisement had specifically stated that the product was not a weight loss product but rather referred to feelings of comfort. In the circumstances, they did not consider that the advertising was in breach of the Code on the basis suggested in the complaint.
Issue 2- Complaint Upheld:
The Council noted the requirements of the Code that a marketing communication should not contain claims – whether direct or indirect, expressed or implied – which a consumer would be likely to regard as being objectively true unless the objective truth of the claims can be substantiated (S. 4.9) and that before offering a marketing communication for publication, advertisers should satisfy themselves that they will be able to provide documentary evidence to substantiate all claims that consumers are likely to regard as objective (S. 4.10).
The Council noted the response that the claims in the advertisement were based on the individual’s experience of using the product, on the volume of customer reviews they had received and based on the use of ingredients backed by research. The Council considered the claims to be claims which a consumer would regard as being objectively true and they noted that no evidence had been provided to substantiate them. In the circumstances, the Council considered that the advertising was in breach of Sections 4.09 and 4.10 of the Code.
Action Required:
The advertisement should not be published in the same format again.
The Council reminded all advertisers of the importance of being able to provide substantiation for claims made or implied in their marketing communications.