Advertisment
A Facebook advertisement (in Dutch) addressed to Belgium residents featured a woman outlining reasons why consumers should switch to Pure The Winery. The Original advert read:-
🥂 Suikervrije Wijn, de hype van nu! 👉🏼
Ontdek de 10 redenen van Suus waarom jij
ook zou moeten overstappen!
Wijn zonder verborgen suikers
Minder calorieën, zelfde plezier
Minder kans op een kater
nog 7 andere redenen 😍
10 Redenen waarom jij
zou moeten …
The English translation was:-
“Sugar-free wine, the hype of the moment!
Discover the 10 reasons from Suus why you should switch too!
1. Wine without hidden sugars
2. Fewer calories, same enjoyment
3. Less chance of a hangover
+ 7 more reasons “
Under the video it stated:
“10 reasons why you should”
There was also a small disclaimer over the video that read:
“Alcohol abuse harms your health.”
The voiceover of the video stated:
“10 Reasons Why Sugar-Free Wine Is the Trend Right Now
Reason number 1
Because these wines contain no sugar, they also contain fewer calories than wines that do contain sugar.
So, they are a more health-conscious choice.
Reason number 2
In addition to containing no sugar, these wines also contain no carbohydrates.
So, if you follow a low-carbohydrate diet, or you simply pay attention to what you drink, these wines are a perfect fit.
Reason number 3
The wines from Pure The Winery contain less sulphites.
And sulphites are precisely the substance that can increase the likelihood of a hangover.
Would you like to read all 10 reasons and find out whether sugar-free wine might be something for you as well?
Then click the link below and read the article I have written.
Cheers!”
The advertisement linked to an article on the blog page of the advertisers’ Dutch website.
An English version of the article stated:
“10 Reasons why sugar-free wine is the hype of today”
The article listed the 10 reasons, which included the following:
“1. Wine without hidden sugars.
Traditional wine is full of hidden sugars. PURE has 0 grams of sugar and 0 carbohydrates, so you know exactly what you are drinking. Pure enjoyment without compromise.
2. Fewer calories, same pleasure.
Because it contains no sugar or carbohydrates, PURE contains up to 30% fewer calories than regular wine. 58 Kcal per 100ml – that really makes a difference if you live consciously.
3. Lower chance of a hangover.
Less sugar also means fewer sulfites (sic), 30 – 50% less than in many other quality wines. Sulfite is precisely the substance that increases the risk of a hangover, so that is a nice bonus!”
“5. Perfect for a conscious lifestyle
Whether you want less sugar, eat low-carb, or simply want to drink healthier: PURE fits effortlessly into your lifestyle. Simple, transparent, and better for you.
For medical reasons, always consult your doctor or dietitian.”
Complaint
A complaint was received from the Belgian government authority responsible for public health. The complainants considered that the advertisements had established a link between the consumption of alcohol and improved health and had included a suggestion that the wines were approved by dietitians.
Response
The advertisers stated that they took their responsibilities regarding the advertising of alcoholic beverages seriously and had carefully reviewed the complaint and the materials referred to.
They said that it had never been their intention to present PURE as a healthy product, to encourage alcohol consumption, or to suggest that consuming PURE provided a health benefit. They said that PURE was an alcoholic wine and should always be consumed responsibly and in moderation.
They said that their communication was intended to explain factual characteristics of their wines, including their sugar, carbohydrate and calorie content, and said these product characteristics were supported by nutritional analyses.
Having reviewed the complaint, they recognised that some of the wording on the referenced “10 Reasons” page could be interpreted more broadly than intended, therefore they had removed the “10 Reasons” page with immediate effect. They also said that they were reviewing their wider marketing communications to ensure that factual product information was clearly distinguished from wording that could imply a health benefit or professional health endorsement. They said that these actions were being taken proactively following their review of the complaint and should not be taken as an admission that the advertising was deliberately misleading or intended to promote irresponsible alcohol consumption.
Conclusion
Complaint Upheld
The Complaints Council considered the detail of the complaint and the advertisers’ response.
The Council noted that the advertisements had included statements as to the benefits of the product such that it included no sugar, no carbohydrates, had few calories and fewer sulphites; and had also included statements such as “less chance of a hangover”, “a more health-conscious choice”, “Pure enjoyment without compromise”, “Perfect for a conscious lifestyle” and “Whether you want less sugar, eat low-carb, or simply want to drink healthier: PURE fits effortlessly into your lifestyle”.
The Council noted the requirements of the Code that marketing communications for alcoholic drinks should be socially responsible and should not exploit the young or the immature. They should neither encourage excessive drinking nor present abstinence or moderation in a negative way (S. 9.1); that they should only depict or imply the responsible and moderate consumption of alcoholic drinks (S. 9.8a); that they may not suggest, or commend, or make fun of over-indulgence in respect of alcohol or its after-effects (S. 9.8f).
While the Council welcomed the action taken by the advertisers in removing the content from their website and social media, they considered that the statements made as to the benefits of the product, including health benefits, were not prepared with a sense of responsibility, and that the claim that less sulphites could provide less chance of a hangover could be seen to be promoting excessive consumption. In the circumstances, they considered the advertising was in breach of Sections 3.3, 9.1 and 9.8f of the Code.
Action Required:
As the advertising had been removed, no further action required. The Council advised advertisers to ensure that advertising for alcoholic products was in line with the Code requirements.