Advertisment
The advertisers’ ’Need a Stairlift?’ website included a facility to obtain a quotation for a stair lift:-
“Get a quote for your new Stairlift in 3 simple steps.”
Step 1 was the type of stairlift required; step 2 was the type of purchase and step 3 was to select the county in Ireland. On selecting the relevant county, various logos of stairlift companies scrolled across the screen. Consumers were then required to submit their name and email address in order to receive the results of their search.
Below the search facility, the website included the following statements:
“Wherever you are, we can find you a stairlift. Our installers cover the entire country; from Sligo to Cork and Dublin to Mayo, our network of stair lift installers have you covered.”
“Our network of stairlift partners cover the whole country and offer a friendly and efficient service that is backed up by outstanding aftercare. Our partners will always conduct a free of charge, no-obligation home assessment to ensure you are getting the right stair lift at the right price. The price you are quoted is always the price you will pay – no hidden charges.”
“Don’t Waste Time Searching For The Best Stairlift Price. We Do That For You!”
“We work with stairlift installers who cover all of Ireland. Our installation teams are certified, insured, VAT registered and council approved so you have complete peace of mind.”
The website also included a section headed “Tips on how to pick the best stairlift installer”, which stated:
“The cheapest isn’t always the best. A stairlift is a significant purchase with most stairlifts costing in excess of €1,999. A stair lift can also be a vital aid to help your elderly parent, relative, or a friend to remain independent and safe. It is therefore essential that you pick the best stairlift and the best stairlift installer.”
It further stated:
“Assessment is key to getting the right stairlift to suit your stairs and more importantly, your needs. Our network of stairlift installers will always conduct a free home visit and assessment before furnishing a quote. This ensures that what you are quoted is what you will pay.
Some companies will quote over the phone but in reality, you cannot see the full picture without physically inspecting the premises. In many cases, the home assessment will highlight issues that may have been easily overlooked.
An experienced stair lift surveyor can also offer advice in regard to getting the best stairlift to suit your needs both now, and in the future.”
In the “Our promise to you” section, the website stated:
“We will listen to your questions and always give you an honest answer. Our network of stairlift partners will only sell you what you need and remain as attentive AFTER your purchase as we were before.”
Complaint
The complainant, BM Stairlifts, objected on the grounds that the website ‘NeedAStairlift.ie’ presented itself as an independent stairlift comparison service that helped customers find the ‘best stairlift provider in your area’ through a network of ‘trusted stairlift installers.’ They considered that the website created the impression that it operated as a neutral service comparing different providers and then directing consumers to the most suitable option.
BM Stairlifts stated that publicly available domain ownership records showed that the website was owned and operated by the advertisers who sold and installed stairlifts. They noted that this relationship was not disclosed on the website or during the enquiry process. They further stated that, although the website displayed multiple stairlift brands and companies’ logos, all test enquiries submitted through the site were directed to the advertisers, regardless of the options selected.
They considered that consumers were likely to believe they were using an independent comparison service. They believed that the website gave a misleading impression of independence and objectivity. They stated that information regarding the website’s ownership was omitted. They believed that the website created the impression that it was impartial, despite all enquiries appearing to be directed to the advertisers. They also considered that the advertising may be particularly misleading for vulnerable customers as purchasers of stairlifts were often elderly or disabled.
Response
The advertisers stated that NeedAStairlift.ie was developed and operated as a consumer-facing lead-generation website for the advertisers’ stairlift installation business. They stated that all enquiries submitted through the website were handled by the advertisers’ own installation teams and were not referred to third-party competitors. They said that the website was not, and had never been, operated as a comparison or aggregator site and did not generate quotes from, or refer enquiries to, third-party stairlift providers.
The advertisers considered that the website was clearly a commercial marketing communication and did not claim to be an independent, neutral or impartial service. However, they accepted that certain elements of the website, particularly the headline “Don’t Waste Time Searching For The Best Stairlift Price. We Do That For You!”, could have suggested a price-comparison service. They also accepted that the identity of the advertisers as the operator of the website had not been displayed clearly enough.
The advertisers stated that they had amended the website to make the advertisers’ ownership clear, removed the comparison-style headline, amended references to “our network” to make clear that enquiries were handled by the advertisers’ own teams, and updated the privacy policy and contact details accordingly. They further stated that the factual claims on the website reflected their actual practices and that documentary evidence was available to substantiate those claims if required.
The advertisers also noted that a standard acknowledgement email was sent to every NeedAStairlift.ie enquiry, showing that it issued in the name of Beechfield Healthcare Ltd.
Conclusion
Complaint Upheld
The Independent Complaints Council considered the detail of the complaint and the advertisers’ response.
The Council noted that the website included a facility for consumers to search for a stairlift quotation and that during that process, logos from various providers were shown, giving the impression that the facility was searching these providers. The Council also noted that the website had included the statement “Don’t Waste Time Searching For The Best Stairlift Price. We Do That For You”.
The Council noted the requirements of the Code that a marketing communication should be designed and presented in such a way that it is clear that it is a marketing communication (S 3.31), marketing communications should not misrepresent their true purpose. Marketing communications should not be presented as, for example, market research, consumer surveys, user-generated content, private blogs, or independent reviews if their purpose is marketing, i.e. the promotion of a product (S. 3.32), and that the identity of the advertiser, product or service should be apparent (S. 3.34).
The Council considered that the website was likely to be viewed by consumers seeking information about stairlifts, many of whom may have little prior knowledge of the market. The Council also noted the requirements of the Code that a marketing communication should not mislead, or be likely to mislead, by inaccuracy, ambiguity, exaggeration, omission or otherwise (S. 4.1) and that advertisers should not exploit the credulity, inexperience or lack of knowledge of consumers (S. 4.4).
The Council considered that consumers were likely to understand the website as an independent service that searched the market or compared providers on their behalf, rather than as a lead-generation website for a single supplier.
The Council also noted that the identity of the advertisers as the operator of the website had not been made sufficiently clear.
Having regard to the overall context in which the advertising was presented, the likely audience, and the impression created by the website as a whole, the Council considered that the advertising was likely to mislead consumers as to the nature, purpose and ownership of the service. Accordingly, they considered the advertising was in breach of Sections 3.31, 3.32, 3.34, 4.1 and 4.4 of the Code.
Action Required:
The Complaints Council told the advertisers to ensure that the website content was absolutely clear as to the nature of the service.