Advertisment
The television advertisement featured a man receiving his MRI results. At the end of the advertisement, a voiceover stated:
“We’ll never leave you waiting. With fast access to MRI and X-ray in five days and results in just two. Switch to Laya Healthcare today.”
On screen text stated:
“MRI and X-ray in 5 days. Results in 2 Days.”
A footnote included:
“Diagnostic imaging provided by [provider name] is subject to referral criteria.
Restrictions apply. MRI scans at selected clinics. Details at layahealthcare.ie/scans”
Complaint
The complainant considered the advertisement misleading as they had never known the service to provide a meaningful result within two days, as claimed in the advertisement. They said that, at the time of their complaint, they had been waiting eight days for the results of an MRI scan and, although they had been notified that the images were available, neither they nor their GP had received the report explaining the scan findings.
Response
The advertisers stated that the advertising referred to diagnostic imaging reporting timeframes available through Laya Health & Wellbeing Clinics, which were based on consistently delivered service standards, high-volume performance data, and agreed contractual service levels with their diagnostic imaging provider. They said that the advertised claim accurately reflected the service delivered to members and was supported by robust, objective and verifiable evidence.
The advertisers stated that 95% of MRI reports were issued within two working days and provided data showing an average report turnaround time of 1.37 working days between Q1 2024 and Q1 2026.
They further stated that MRI reporting times had consistently remained within the advertised timeframe, with average turnaround times ranging between approximately one and two working days during the relevant period. They provided details of the average wait times per quarter between 2024 and 2026 as evidence.
While acknowledging that individual cases could occasionally take longer due to clinical or operational factors, they maintained that such exceptions did not undermine the accuracy of the advertising claim, which they said was supported by high-volume performance data, service level agreements, and governance processes.
Conclusion
Complaint Not Upheld.
The Independent Complaints Council considered the detail of the complaint and the advertisers’ response.
The Council noted that the advertisement stated that consumers could access MRI and X-ray services within five days and receive results within two days. The Council noted the requirements of the Code that a marketing communication should not mislead, or be likely to mislead, by inaccuracy, ambiguity, exaggeration, omission or otherwise (S. 4.1) and that before offering a marketing communication for publication, advertisers should satisfy themselves that they will be able to provide documentary evidence to substantiate all claims that consumers are likely to regard as objective (S. 4.10).
The Council noted that information had been provided to show that 95% of MRI reports were issued within two working days and that details had been provided showing reporting timeframes of between one and two working days
While the Council acknowledged the complainant’s experience of waiting longer than two days for an MRI report, they considered that the impression created by the advertisement was that the claim was being made in regard to the typical timeframes within which MRI reports were provided and that individual cases did not in themselves demonstrate that the advertising claim was inaccurate. As the advertising claim had been supported by evidence showing that reports were, in the vast majority of cases, issued within the advertised timeframe, the Council did not consider the advertising was in breach of the Code on the grounds raised.
Action Required:
No further action is required.