Advertisment
The advertisement was a television advertisement. The advertisement featured various scenes of typical domestic life at Christmas. A boy was seen in the scenes collecting his family’s used plastic bottles and aluminium cans.
The script of the voiceover was: –
“In Ireland, we know a thing or two about doing things the right way. But not all of us are recycling the right way just yet. Putting cans and bottles in your mixed recycling bin isn’t as good as returning. When they’re kept separate, more can be recycled again and again. So this Christmas, return it right.”
Complaint
Three complaints were received regarding the advertisement.
Issue 1:
Two complainants alleged that the advertisement implied that the Re-Turn scheme was better than household recycling. Both complainants considered that traditional recycling generally was the same as recycling via the DRS (deposit return scheme) as using either meant the item was recycled.
One of the complainants said that no substantiation was in evidence as to why this was the case and believed the advertisers had confused a quantitative measure – improved recycling rates- with a qualitative one (the quality of said recycling).
Issue 2:
Two of the complaints alleged that the advertisers’ scheme had a larger carbon footprint than household recycling. These complainants alleged that when the whole infrastructure of the advertisers’ scheme was taken into account, such as the servicing and power usage of the machines and the additional car journeys necessitated by travel to the recycling points, that this scheme was less carbon efficient than traditional ‘green bin’ recycling.
Issue 3:
One of the complainants was insulted that the advertisement implied Irish people were bad at recycling.
Issue 4:
One complainant considered that the advertisement had not stated that only bottles or cans with the Re-Turn logo could be recycled.
Response
Issue 1:
The advertisers said that the statement the specific statement in the advertisement was, ‘Putting cans and bottles in your mixed recycling bin isn’t as good as Re-turning. When they’re kept separate, more can be recycled again and again.’
The advertisers stated that evidence showed that separate collection reduced exposure to other waste and contamination, produced materially cleaner recyclate and made bottle-to-bottle recycling more achievable. They referred to Re-turn’s 2024 Annual Report which recorded material purity in excess of 99%. They said that a 2025 academic evidence review similarly found strong evidence that DRS collection produced higher-quality secondary raw materials and that DRS material was substantially less contaminated than material from other collection methods.
They also said that the peer-reviewed 2025 evidence review reached the same conclusion, reporting strong evidence that DRS collection produced secondary raw materials of much higher quality than other methods; that recycled PET from DRS was substantially less contaminated; and that keeping beverage packaging separate made the material more suitable for food-contact applications and closed-loop recycling.
They believed that this evidence directly substantiated the script used in the advertisement: that keeping eligible containers separate meant that more of the material could remain suitable for recycling repeatedly. They also said the wording was deliberately qualified before broadcast to state, “more can be recycled again and again”.
They advertisers also pointed out that the advertisement did not say or imply that containers placed in mixed recycling were never recycled; that mixed recycling was ineffective or should no longer be used; or that every plastic item could be returned through their scheme.
Issue 2:
The advertisers said that the advertisements did not make a general lifecycle claim regarding the operation of their scheme. They said that their comparison was expressly limited to recycling outcomes arising from keeping the relevant material separate. They said that the advertisement had not claimed that DRS was environmentally superior on every measure or across every lifecycle stage across everything; or that DRS caused no environmental impact.
They said that Re-turn commissioned Eunomia, an independent sustainability consultancy, to compare the climate impact of the relevant beverage-container waste system with and without DRS. They said that Eunomia’s 2024 analysis included RVM (reverse vending machine) operation, scheme overheads, logistics, sorting, incineration, landfill, and recycling. The study identified additional emissions from logistics and scheme administration but found these were more than offset by higher recycling and reduced incineration. On the report’s stated assumptions and system boundary, they said that the introduction of DRS reduced the climate impact by an estimated 66,900 tonnes of CO₂ in 2024 and increased the effective recycling rate for the relevant PET, aluminium, and steel containers from approximately 45% to 78% (at that point in time, it is now 90%+).
Issue 3:
The advertisers said that the advertisement did not say that Irish people generally failed to recycle properly. They said that the actual line used was, “But not all of us are recycling the right way, just yet”. This was followed immediately by the specific comparison of cans and bottles in mixed recycling. They said that in the context of the campaign’s light-hearted “right way” theme, the line referred to the route used for DRS-eligible drinks containers and that it was not a criticism of household recycling as a whole or of the public. They said that the words “not all of us” and “just yet” were inclusive and acknowledged an incomplete behaviour change, rather than condemning consumers.
Issue 4:
The advertisers said the advertisement did not claim that every plastic item or every container could be returned. They said that it had depicted drink cans and bottles in a branded Re-turn context and communicated a comparative recycling message, rather than attempting to provide a complete explanation of scheme eligibility within a short television execution. They said that Re-turn’s consumer information, including the Annual Report and scheme guidance, explained that eligible containers bore the Re-turn logo and that omitting the full eligibility criteria from this advertisement did not alter or render misleading the specific claim being made.
Further Information:
The ASA Executive noted that the Re-Turn scheme was launched on 1st February 2024 (https://re-turn.ie/about-us/)
Sidorczuk-Pietraszko, E., Piontek, W. and Larsson, A. (2025) ‘Are Deposit–Return Schemes an Optimal Solution for Beverage Container Collection in the European Union? An Evidence Review’, Sustainability, 17(19), Article 8791. Available at: https://doi.org/10.3390/su17198791
Conclusion
Conclusion: Complaints Not Upheld.
The Independent Complaints Council considered the detail of the complaint and the advertisers’ response.
Issue 1- Complaints Not Upheld:
The Council noted the substantiation that had been provided for the claims made in the advertisement which demonstrated the benefits of the advertised scheme over household recycling. They did not consider that the advertisement was in breach of the Code on the basis suggested in the complaints.
Issue 2 – Complaints Not Upheld:
The Council noted that the advertisement claim related to recycling outcomes when relevant material was kept separated and that the advertisement had not made a general lifecycle claim regarding the operation of the scheme.
The Council also noted the evidence provided regarding the environmental impact of the DRS scheme. The Council did not consider that a breach of the Code had arisen on the basis suggested in the complaints.
Issue 3- Complaint Not Upheld:
The Council in noting that the advertisement had stated “But not all of us are recycling the right way just yet”, did not consider that the advertisement implied that all Irish people were bad at recycling. They therefore did not consider that the advertisement was in breach of the Code on the basis suggested in the complaint.
Issue 4- Complaint Not Upheld:
The Council noted that the advertisement had prominently displayed the Re-Turn logo on the end frame of the advertisement. They also noted that the scheme had launched on 1st February 2024 and therefore considered that there would be a general understanding amongst consumers how the scheme worked. In the circumstances they did not consider that the advertisement was in breach of the Code on the basis suggested in the complaint.
Action Required:
No further action required.