Lidl Ireland objected to the advertising on the following grounds.
Issue 1:
The complainants considered that the headline claim of ‘hundreds of low prices’ dropping lower was misleading as the product list on the advertisers’ website only comprised of 102 products.
The complainants also believed that there had been a headline in a press advertisement that stated “over 500 products” (NB no advertisement with this claim has been provided to or located by the Executive) which they considered was misleading.
Issue 2:
The complainants considered that the savings claim of ‘up to 20%’ in the press advertisement was misleading. The complainants noted that the price drop webpage had provided the ‘Was’ and ‘Now’ prices for the sample trolley shop and after aggregating the savings outlined, noted that they amounted to a saving of €22.38 (€232.06 – €209.68) which they said equated to a reduction of 9.6% as opposed to the advertised saving of ‘up to 20%’.
The advertisers responded to the issues raised.
Issue 1:
The advertisers said that none of their advertising had stated that there were ‘over 500 products’ and they believed the complainants were incorrect on this matter.
They said that the text of the advertisements simply referred to ‘hundreds’ of prices.
Issue 2:
The advertisers said that it was clear from the advertising that the savings were circa 18%. They said that the statement in the advertisement was that your weekly shop is now “up to 20% cheaper”, which they said did not mean that every product would be 20% cheaper.
Further Information:
An analysis of the Price Drops List on the advertisers’ website was conducted by the ASA Executive.
| Metric | Overall | Sample Trolley Shop | Other Price Drops |
|---|
| Number of products | 213 | 32 | 181 |
| Total Was | €485.48 | €90.68 | €394.80 |
| Total Now | €437.64 | €72.18 | €365.46 |
| Total Saving | €47.84 | €18.50 | €29.34 |
| Weighted % Reduction | 9.9% | 20.04% | 7.4% |
| Average Saving per Product | €0.22 | €0.58 | €0.16 |
| Average % Reduction | 10.0% | 19.8% | 8.3% |
Source: Trolley Radio Other LIST JUL26 10015887 AF LR 03.pdf