Advertisment
Advert 1 – Social Media Video post on advertisers’ own Facebook account.
Text of post: “GoMo Fibre Broadband is here. €29.99 a month for life. Only at GoMo.ie”
Voiceover of video:
“..just €29.99 a month for life. Ireland’s only price for life fibre broadband. No sudden price hikes, no surprising price spikes. Just €29.99 a month, for life. Even in 2099 it will still be €29.99. Go GoMo fibre broadband at GoMo.ie and lock in €29.99 a month for life today.”
A disclaimer appeared during the video to say “T&C’s Apply”.
Advert 2 – TV Advertisement
Voiceover: “GoMo is going fibre broadband. Just €29.99 a month. Ireland’s only price for life fibre broadband. No sudden price hikes, no surprising price spikes. Just €29.99 a month, for life. Even in 2099 it will still be €29.99. Go GoMo fibre broadband at GoMo.ie and lock in €29.99 a month for life today.”
A footnote/disclaimer on screen at beginning of advert stated:
“Subject to location and availability. 30 Day contract. €49.99 activation fee applies.”
Footnote/Disclaimer on screen in middle of advert:
“Available only with GoMo Mobile. For full T&C’s see GoMo.ie”
The website address ‘GoMo.ie’ was on screen for the last 10 seconds of the advertisement.
Advert 3 – Website
The broadband webpage on the advertisers’ website included the following:
“HURRY, FIRST 10,000 CUSTOMERS!
GoMo Fibre Broadband
30 Day contract. One simple plan. Unlimited broadband. No Landline, no fuss.
€29.99 a month for life.
Lock in this price for life”
Beneath was a box to enter an Eircode and beside the box was a button labelled “Can I get broadband?”
Underneath this section it stated:
“Reasons to love GoMo Fibre Broadband!”
One of the reasons listed was:
“GoMo Family
GoMo Fibre Broadband is an exclusive offer for new or existing
GoMo Mobile customers.”
Further down the webpage it stated:
“Already a GoMo Mobile customer?
GoMo Fibre Broadband was designed exclusively for the GoMo Family. Lock in unlimited fibre broadband at a price for life today. It’s super simple!”
Advert 4 – Outdoor
A 48 sheet post stated:
“GoMo Fibre Broadband Is Here!
€29.99 A Month For Life!”
The poster also stated “Terms Apply” and included the web address “GoMo.ie”.
Complaint
Imagine Communications Group and Sky Ireland objected to the advertising.
Issue 1 – Advert 1 and 4:
Imagine considered the headline “€29.99 a month for life” claim in the outdoor and social media advertisements was misleading because the offer was subject to a number of significant conditions, none of which were disclosed in the main advertising:
1. only available to existing or new GoMo mobile customers;
2. The €29.99 price includes a €10/month discount that depends on continuing to hold the GoMo mobile service;
3. If a customer moves home at any point, the entire “For Life” promotion is automatically terminated and they forfeit the advertised price altogether;
4. GoMo expressly reserves the right to amend, vary or withdraw any element of the “For Life” promotion at any time, without notice;
5. offer is available only to the first 10,000 customers to sign up;
6. once-off broadband activation fee of €49.99 applies, which is not mentioned in the headline;
7. service is only available on the GoMo Broadband Network. Consumers served by SIRO, NBI or Virgin Media networks cannot buy the product, even though the advertising does not say so.
They considered that the disclosures “Terms Apply” (outdoor advertisement) and “T&C’s Apply” (Facebook video) were not adequate as they had not qualified the “€29.99 a month for life” claim by providing any detail as to what the terms were. They accepted that the words ‘Terms Apply’ on the poster was legible, however, they considered that it, and ‘T&C’s apply’ statement on the social media post, did not correct the impression created by the headline, and the actual material terms of the offer were therefore not disclosed to the consumer at the point at which the advertising claim was made
They said that outdoor advertising was, by definition, seen by consumers when they were on the move and that social media advertising was seen in short dwell-times, typically on small screens. They did not believe that the likely audience for these advertisements would understand from the headline that the offer was conditional on holding a separate mobile contract, was capped at 10,000 customers, was subject to a broadband activation fee, was lost if the consumer moves home, was varied or withdrawn at the advertiser’s discretion, and was only available on one network.
Issue 2 – Advert 4:
Imagine considered the size and placement of the ‘Terms Apply’ statement at the bottom left of the outdoor poster made it ‘barely legible’ from a normal pedestrian or vehicle viewing distance.
Issue 3 – Advert 1:
Imagine considered the words “T&Cs Apply” on the social media post had appeared only briefly during the video and that it was in a colour and font that made it difficult to see.
Issue 4 – Advert 3:
Imagine considered the website landing page was misleading as it did not include any reference to terms and conditions applying.
Issue 5 – Advert 3:
Sky Ireland considered that the claim in the website advertising that the offer was limited to 10,000 customers had created an impression of scarcity and urgency that was designed to pressure customers into signing up quickly without undertaking adequate comparison shopping. As the limit of 10,000 customers had subsequently been removed, they questioned whether it represented a genuine intention to limit the offer or whether it was a marketing device to create urgency.
Response
Issue 1 – Advert 1 and 4:
The advertisers stated that consumers were familiar with the use of “for life” in GoMo advertising as meaning that a qualifying customer who remained on the offer retained the pricing indefinitely, rather than only for a limited introductory period. They said the offer delivered exactly that and that unlike many broadband offers in the market, the price did not automatically increase after six, twelve or twenty-four months. They said that the “For Life” claim therefore distinguished GoMo from time-limited offer pricing structures commonly used in the sector.
They said that they had offered a price-for-life proposition since its launch in October 2019 as a mobile operator and since then, no GoMo mobile customer had received a price increase, demonstrating that GoMo had consistently delivered on its price-for-life promise in practice.
They said that the conditions were clearly set out in the terms and conditions applicable to the offer and that the terms were taken directly from GoMo’s published terms and conditions and were made available to consumers as part of the promotion. As such, they considered that the relevant conditions were disclosed and accessible to consumers. They said that consumers engaging with the offer online were informed of the eligibility requirements before purchase and before entering into any contract.
They said that GoMo Fibre Broadband could only be purchased through GoMo.ie and that no consumer could sign up without being directed through that online journey and having access to the relevant terms and conditions. They noted that the Code did not require every eligibility criterion or condition to be reproduced in full within every advertising execution, particularly in media such as outdoor advertising where space was inherently limited. In addition, they said that the TV and radio advertisements expressly called out the applicable terms, including that the offer was subject to availability, was only available with GoMo mobile, that a €49.99 activation fee applied, and that a 30-day minimum term contract applied.
They said that conditions regarding activation fees, network availability restrictions and circumstances when a customer may cease to qualify for the offer were standard commercial and operational conditions commonly associated with telecommunications products. They did not alter the truth of the core claim that qualifying customers could obtain GoMo Fibre Broadband at €29.99 per month for life. They considered that these matters were appropriately addressed through the offer terms and conditions rather than within the headline claim itself.
They referred to other advertisements in the campaign, stating that the TV and radio advertisements expressly called out the applicable terms, including that the offer was subject to availability, was only available with GoMo mobile, that a €49.99 activation fee applied, and that a 30-day minimum term contract applied.
In regard to the complaint concerning the adequacy of the use of “Terms Apply” and “T&C’s Apply”, the advertisers submitted that the qualifications were appropriate in the context of the media used. They said that outdoor, social and display advertising were necessarily concise formats and that it would be impractical and detrimental to consumer understanding to reproduce detailed terms in each execution. “Terms Apply” alerted consumers that eligibility conditions applied and that further information was available, which was common industry practice for advertising campaigns and well understood by consumers. They noted that the complainant themselves used conditions when advertising their own products and services.
They said that all GoMo advertising directed consumers to GoMo.ie, where the relevant terms and conditions were easily accessible within two clicks, which they considered was consistent with applicable guidance and common practice across the telecommunications sector.
Issue 2 – Advert 4:
The advertisers noted from the complaint at Issue 2, that the complainants considered that the “Terms Apply” wording was legible, and that they had said that consumers usually viewed outdoor advertising while moving. In view of this, the advertisers believed that the wording was therefore capable of being seen and read in context, and consumers were directed to GoMo.ie to access full offer information before purchase.
They submitted that the advertising campaign was clear and transparent because it stated that terms applied and believed that the font size was compliant with the Code, particularly as all relevant and material terms and conditions were available through the GoMo website and purchase journey before any contractual commitment was made.
Issue 3 – Advert 1:
The advertiser did not provide a comment on this aspect of the complaint.
Issue 4 – Advert 3:
The advertisers stated that the conditions were clearly set out in the terms and conditions applicable to the offer. They said that the terms were taken directly from GoMo’s published terms and conditions and were made available to consumers as part of the promotion, as such, the relevant conditions were disclosed and accessible to consumers.
They said that consumers engaging with the offer online were informed of the eligibility requirements before purchase and before entering into any contract. They said that GoMo Fibre Broadband could only be purchased through GoMo.ie, and that no consumer could sign up without being directed through that online journey and having access to the relevant terms and conditions. They noted that the Code did not require every eligibility criterion or condition to be reproduced in full within every advertising execution, particularly in media such as outdoor advertising where space was inherently limited. In addition, they said that the TV and radio advertisements expressly called out the applicable terms, including that the offer was subject to availability, was only available with GoMo mobile, that a €49.99 activation fee applied, and that a 30-day minimum term contract applied.
Issue 5 – Advert 3:
The advertisers said that the customer limitation which formed part of the offer was genuine, was clearly communicated at launch last May and was reflected in the applicable offer terms and conditions. They said that the suggestion that the customer limitation was artificial, removed or exceeded was incorrect, as the offer was still active and in situ. They said that the central premise of the complaint appeared to be that the absence of the “first 10,000 customers” wording in certain subsequent marketing materials demonstrated that the original claim was not genuine. They considered that this conclusion did not follow. They considered that the relevant question for the purposes of the ASAI Code was whether the claim in the offer was truthful and substantiated when made, and they said that it had been. They said that the customer limitation formed part of the offer, was clearly disclosed to consumers and was supported by the offer terms and conditions. They said that the fact that marketing executions evolved over the course of the GoMo advertising campaign did not alter the accuracy of the offer, i.e. the current price for any prospective customer seeking to sign up to GoMo fibre broadband was €29.99 a month for life.
The advertisers disagreed that the offer created a sense of urgency which could cause harm as it would pressure consumers into signing up quickly without undertaking adequate comparison shopping. They said that such a statement was clearly false and misleading as (1) prospective broadband customers normally shopped around for the best value offers for the provision of fibre broadband as various fibre broadband providers had competitive promotions in the marketplace and (2) there were a number of well-established aggregator/ comparison websites such as bonkers.ie and switcher.ie which provided details of various broadband offers available in the marketplace.
They said that no evidence has been provided that the customer limitation which formed part of the offer was not genuine, that it was exceeded, or that consumers were misled in relation to the offer. They considered that assessment should instead be based on the facts as they existed at the time of the launch of the offer and as they existed today. They noted the statement that if GoMo subsequently extended the offer, earlier customers would have been misled and they believed that this statement was disingenuous as customers who availed of the offer would have received exactly what was advertised: Fibre Broadband at €29.99 per month for life, subject to the applicable offer terms and conditions. They said that there was no evidence that consumers were unable to avail of the advertised offer, that the offer was unavailable as advertised, or that any consumer suffered detriment because of the offer. The advertisers said the customer limitation was genuine and still applied, however, with any marketing campaign, they review the outcome of that campaign, and reserve the right, like any other operator, to put in place a new offer or vary or amend the existing offer if the market dictates that there is an appetite for such a competitive price point for the provision of fibre broadband.
Conclusion
Complaints Upheld In Part.
The Complaints Council considered the detail of the complaints and the advertisers’ response.
Issue 1 – Complaint Upheld:
The Complaints Council noted that both the social media and outdoor advertisements had included a notification that terms applied and had also included the website address, with the social media advertisement including an explicit direction to the website.
The Council noted the requirements of the Code that a marketing communication should not mislead, or be likely to mislead, by inaccuracy, ambiguity, exaggeration, omission or otherwise (S. 4.1); that advertisers should not exploit the credulity, inexperience or lack of knowledge of consumers (S. 4.4).
In this case the Council noted that the complainants considered that all significant conditions should have been included in the advertising. The Council considered this against the requirements of the Code against the type of media used. While the Council did not consider that all significant conditions related the offer were required to be included in the advertisements, they considered that both advertisements should have included a notification that the product was only available to GoMo mobile customers, that an activation fee applied and, as the service was subject to geographical restrictions, that the service was subject to location and availability. In the absence of these conditions in the outdoor and social media advertising, the Council considered the advertisements in breach of Sections 4.1, 4.4 and 4.28 of the Code.
Issue 2 – Complaint Not Upheld:
The Council noted the complainant’s concerns regarding the size and placement of the reference to ‘Terms Apply’ on the outdoor poster. The Council considered the requirements of the Code that footnote or “small print” information should be of sufficient size and/or prominence and be located and presented in such a manner as to be clearly and easily legible and/or audible; where appropriate such information should be linked to the relevant part of the main copy (S. 4.6). In this case the Council considered that the size and legibility of the ‘Terms Apply’ were sufficient and therefore did not consider that the outdoor advertisement was in breach of the Code on the grounds raised in Issue 2.
Issue 3 – Complaint Upheld:
The Council noted the complaint was made on the grounds that the disclaimer “T&C’s Apply” had only been displayed on the video advertisement for a brief period and that the colour of the font made it difficult to read. The Council considered the requirements of the Code that footnote or “small print” information should be of sufficient size and/or prominence and be located and presented in such a manner as to be clearly and easily legible and/or audible and where appropriate such information should be linked to the relevant part of the main copy (S. 4.6). In this case the Council noted that the text had appeared on screen for approximately 4 seconds out of a 30 second video and they considered that the font used had affected the clarity of the words. In the circumstances, they considered that the social media advertisement was in breach of Section 4.6 of the Code.
Issue 4 – Complaint Upheld:
The Council noted that the complaint had been made on the grounds that no indication had been made on the broadband webpage that the product was subject to any terms and conditions. The Council noted that the webpage had included a direction to enter an Eircode to see if the product was available and that it had stated at two sections that the product was available only to existing GoMo mobile customers and that the bottom of the website had included a link to the general terms. The Council noted that the only way to sign up for the product was through the website, and they noted from the response that customers engaging with the offer online were informed of the eligibility requirements before purchase and before entering into any contract.
The Council noted the requirements of the Code, including that compliance with the Code was assessed in the light of a marketing communication’s probable effect when taken as a whole and in context (S. 2.4). While the Complaints Council noted that there was a link at the bottom of the website to the general terms, they considered that consumers should not have to go searching for terms, and that there should be a statement sufficiently close to the offer that linked directly to the relevant terms. In the absence of such information, the Council considered that the advertisement could mislead and therefore was in breach of Sections 4.1 and 4.4 of the Code.
Issue 5 – Complaint Not Upheld:
The Council noted that the advertisement had included the statement “Hurry, First 10,000 Customers” and that as the statement was no longer in use, the complainant’s considered that the limit had been removed and the offer was subsequently available to more than 10,000 customers. The Council noted from the response that the limit was still in place and as such, they did not consider that the advertising was in breach of the Code on the grounds raised.
Action Required:
The social media, outdoor and webpage advertisements should not reappear in their current form.